Ok heres my opinion and this is how I would judge this horse if he was presented before me. Starting from the head.The eye could be set a little lower even though there appears to be good width between the eyes and the eyes are lovely and large and open.. The ears a little long.The nostril placement and width is good. The gullet attachment to neck isnt bad and he's nice and fine through that area . The length of neck not too bad.Moving onto the shoulders ,I feel this horse is a little straight in the shoulder even though the neck set/ shoulder attachment reasonable. He does have reasonable depth of girth ,is nicely coupled and reasonably good hip to buttock length even though the tail set is a little low for my liking. Moving on to legs,I feel this horse is slightly tied in behind the knee on the off fore. His pastern axis is ok.from the bottom photo it looks like he might toe out slightly on the near fore but its a little hard to tell without a front on shot. Moving onto hind legs,he's a little weak through the thighs and gaskins and a little too straight through the hind legs. Overall though he's quite a nicely balanced horse. I would like to see a direct behind and in front shot to judge those areas. JMHO,dont hate me for it,you asked for an honest critique!!